AI Commentary and Scenario analysis
The commentary that plays alongside a trade replay, the Hindsight Score and the what-if scenarios VEXA works out from your own fills.
On this page
What this does
Two AI features live inside Trade Replay. AI Commentary talks you through the trade as it plays. The AI tab scores the finished trade and shows what you could have done differently.
Both start from the same review of your trade. VEXA works out every number itself, from your own fills and the price candles: how much was open at each moment, your best and worst point, what each alternative would have made. The AI then explains those numbers in words. It does not make any of them up, and a sentence that quotes a figure VEXA did not compute is replaced before you see it.
Before you start
Both need VEXA Pro. The trade page and Trade Replay itself are free on every plan, but AI Commentary and the AI tab are Pro features. See Free, Edge and Pro compared.
Both are web only, because they live inside Trade Replay, which is web only.
The AI tab uses hindsight. VEXA says so at the top of the tab: these use prices you could not see at the time. A score is a measurement of the gap between what you did and what the chart turned out to allow, not a grade on your judgement in the moment.
Steps
Web only
- Open the trade from Trades or from a Journal day card.
- Click Replay Trade in the header.
- AI commentary sits under the playback controls. Collapse it, or click Hide to replay without it.
- For the score and the what-ifs, open the AI tab in the side panel.
- Click a what-if to jump the replay to its moment. Use Hide on chart to take the markers off the chart.
- In the AI tab, click anywhere on the chart to test an exit at that price.
What the commentary gives you
The commentary follows your trade’s real moments: your entry, each time you added or took some off, the trade’s best and worst point, your exit, and what price did after you left when that matters.
- The moment the replay is on is shown in full, with the time and the emotional state VEXA infers from what you did.
- Every moment is listed underneath with its time. Click one to jump there. Moments ahead of the replay show only their name, so the ending is not given away.
- Tick Pause at each moment to have playback stop at every one.
- Once the replay reaches your exit, a short summary of how the trade likely felt appears.
The commentary reads your fills the way they happened. If you added to a position that was losing, it says so rather than calling it conviction.
What the AI tab gives you
Summary. Two or three sentences on the trade as a whole.
Hindsight Score. A score out of 100, from four parts. It is worked out by formula, so the same trade always gets the same score. How the score works in the tab spells it out:
| Part | Weight | What it measures |
|---|---|---|
| Entry | 25% | Where your average entry sat in the price range of the trade’s first 15 minutes |
| Exit | 30% | How much of the best realistic exit you kept; for a trade never in profit, how much of the worst drawdown you avoided |
| Risk | 30% | Your worst drawdown against your planned or chart risk; adding to a loser costs 15 points |
| Hold | 15% | How much of the open profit you kept; for a losing trade, how little of the hold was spent in the red |
What if. Up to four alternatives, each with the dollar amount it would have made or saved:
- Best realistic exit. Closing everything at a candle’s close while you held it, not at the single best tick, which nobody can sell.
- Better entry. Only a price that actually traded in the first 15 minutes, before you took anything off.
- Stop loss. VEXA uses the stop you entered on the trade’s Risk tab. Without one, it uses the low (or, for a short, the high) of the candles before your entry, then 1.5 times the average candle range. It then checks what the price actually did: the stop would have saved money, would have stopped you out before a recovery, or was never hit.
- Holding longer. What the shares you sold were worth 15, 30 or 60 minutes after your exit, shown only when the move was bigger than the chart’s normal noise.
Every figure is net of your fees and uses the contract multiplier, so it compares directly with your real result.
Coaching. Three lessons from this trade and one rule for next time.
Key facts. Your best and worst point, the minutes spent in the red, the fees, and what you did well or badly (for example, taking profit into strength, or adding to a loser).
How to use it
Every chart has a better entry and a better exit in hindsight. One trade’s what-ifs are not a verdict. The pattern across many trades is: if Holding longer keeps appearing and your Exit score stays low, that is the same habit seen twice. See Rate a trade.
What you should see
While the review runs, the commentary reads “Reading your fills against the chart” and the AI tab shows placeholders. The first time you open a trade this can take a few seconds. After that the review is kept, and opening the trade again is instant.
If it doesn’t work
The panels are locked. AI Commentary and the AI tab need Pro. The rest of the trade page stays free either way.
An error with Try again. The review did not finish. Click Try again. If the AI itself is unavailable, VEXA still shows the score, the what-ifs and the facts, with plainer wording.
Nothing appears. The review reads the candles the replay is playing. A trade with no chart data has nothing to review. See Why a chart is blank.
Related
Still stuck? Email support@vexatrade.ai.